Uncle Joe’s Pizzeria

99 N Genesee St, Geneva, NY 14456, USA

About Uncle Joe’s Pizzeria

4.5 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Gary Wurstner
    September 02, 2022

    Uncle Joe's is a combination sit down restaurant and pizza takeout joint. You enter on the pizzeria side (which appeared quite busy judging by the activity in the kitchen) and wait to be seated on the restaurant side. That was our only complaint, and a minor one at that. We waited what seemed like a long time to be seated, even though were open tables and booths. Other than that, everything was great. The food was delicious and our server was terrific. They have a large menu, with a full page of lunch specials.

    Chris Savage
    July 19, 2022

    My girlfriend has wanted to come here for quite some time so I decided to try it out. It was a nice change from the same pizza we usually have. This was a unique experience for us that started with complimentary Italian bread, which was delicious! The butter was cold and so I ended using the spread, even though I know it would have tasted better with real butter. We got a side of sauce to enjoy the crust after eating the main part of the pizza. While we enjoyed the pizza, there is one request...more toppings! The pizza we got was sparse on pepperoni and sausage (see photo). The third photo is the one we saw in someone else's review and made us want to order that exact pizza. Ours had much less toppings. I'm hoping next time to get one closer to that pizza. If so we'll go 5 stars!

    Sekaya (Kaya)
    January 27, 2023

    Oh my god. So hospitable. Family oriented and authentic. 😍Beautiful, classic atmosphere. Consistency. 👍🏽♥️😍Plenty to look at as there are so many historic images and memorabilia alto keep you busy. And the cheese pull on our pizza was just 😘♥️amazing. Delicious flavors. We ordered a Cesar salad 🥗 yumm! Absolutely an authentic taste for a Cesar salad. I would only suggest that the FRESH garlic bread pieces used be baked, GRILLED or broiled to crusty perfection to add that perfect “crunch,” “crusty bread” otherwise the flavor is all there. Wow. And the big Al we opted for Turkey. We absolutely could not finish everything. So delicious!!! Will be returning!

    Basem Yunis
    June 23, 2022

    Fresh ingredients. The greens and beans was yummy. We also had a small pizza and eggplant parmesan sub. Sub was good. I was expecting a NY style pizza, but it wasn't. Way too thick almost a Chicago style feel but not as thick. Everything is homemade the menu has many options. Did not have wings, many other patrons did they looked good. Italian bread is homemade that's enough reason to try this place. Our server was excellent!!

    Rebecca FA
    July 30, 2022

    We destroyed our pizza! Pepperoni and fresh mushrooms (crazy people can choose canned). The 🍗 s were hot and crispy. Buffalo sauce choices were hot or mild. We got mild. Unfortunately it was kind of oily and flavorless like maybe it wasn't butter? I had to tell my husband to stop swirling it around and tasting it. The flavor wasn't going to change. We took the leftovers home and we will make some Frank's and butter buffalo sauce for them. The staff here are super nice and the porch was a fun spot ☺️

    Uncle Joe’s Pizzeria

    Our Address

    99 N Genesee St, Geneva, NY 14456, USA

    See Your Business Here!

    For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!