Supernatural Lake

7930 County Rd 153, Interlaken, NY 14847, USA

About Supernatural Lake

4.5 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Lillian Reape
    August 27, 2020

    We stayed in one of the cabins and were originally only planning on eating here the first night but the food, wine list, staff and atmosphere were so amazing we continued to go back each night it was open. I especially loved the fried green tomato BLT (probably the best BLT I've ever had). The staff is fantastic. Very nice and knowledgeable and were always able to help us pair the perfect wine with our dinners. Hopefully this is a yearly pop-up! Would love to go back next summer!

    Carl Cadregari
    August 28, 2020

    Wonderful people, friendly and very accommodatting. Services was spot on and Sarah and Katherine (and every one else!) were just great, friendly and helpful. The atmosphere is nicely casual, great view of the lake. Food was quite good with several local items. And the wine list...I’ve been to a lot of “wine” bars that had 5, 10, even 25 different offerings...but there’s at least 3 dozen just sparkling wines on the list!! Even a Brut Nature which I never see. The list is French forward, but has some fantastic German (had an outstanding Spatlese Riesling with dinner👍 that Katherine recommended) Great Finger Lakes and California offerings too. We will be back soon with family and friends!

    Nisha Chittal
    September 03, 2020

    Had an amazing time! We also stayed in the cottages Supernatural Lake is renting out, and dined at the restaurant three times in our week-long stay. Top notch wine selection, great service from a friendly and welcoming team, and the food is delicious and seasonal and locally sourced. Loved the fried green tomato BLT, the trout roll, and the potato wedges. And the Friday pig roast was really fun. Highly recommend for dinner and drinks, and if you're coming from out of town for a Finger Lakes excursion, stay in their cottages too, we had a great stay there -- perfect location right on the water, beautiful views! The Compagnie team has done a great job with this spot.

    Lisa Ganz
    September 06, 2020

    Total food and wine paradise. My husband and I had the pleasure of staying as cottage guests at Supernatural for our one year wedding anniversary. We've visited their wine bar in NYC many times, and trusted that any place that same team was behind would be first rate. We were right. The accommodations were adorable and the setting right on the lake with games, activities, and ridiculous sunrises was something we'll never forget. Sarah went out of her way to make it special for us and was quick to respond before and during our stay. The star though is the restaurant (and the wine, of course), which you can enjoy even if you're not a guest of the cottages. Chef Eric is so talented and is finally getting the spotlight he deserves at this place, since the wine is front and center at the city spot. Anything you order will be great and the wine, beer, and cocktail selection are perfectly curated. Make a reservation at the restaurant and enjoy a glass of wine and some corn hole on the lake before your dinner. Any review on here that's not 5 stars is utterly ridiculous by the way :) Thank you, Supernatural team!!!

    Helena Dona
    August 03, 2020

    We came here late in the afternoon for dinner. The restaurant outdoor seating faces the lake, there was great music on and it felt perfect! The food is amazing, everything tastes super fresh. We ordered the heirloom tomatoes, green salad and corn to start. Everything was very tasty but the tomatoes were spectacular! The ingredients are simple, but of incredible, fresh quality, all locally sourced. You can taste it in every bite. The wedges were the best we have ever had,super crispy! Finally we ordered the BLT and Trout roll and they were both delicious! The wine selections is great and the staff are super friendly and cheerful! If you are in the Finger Lakes you cannot miss this place! Ah and by the way ... the s’mores ice cream Sunday was delicious!

    Supernatural Lake

    Our Address

    7930 County Rd 153, Interlaken, NY 14847, USA

    See Your Business Here!

    For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!