Rico’s Pizza New York Style

371 W Morris St, Bath, NY 14810, USA

About Rico’s Pizza New York Style

4 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    January 20, 2022

    Ordered a large cheese pizza with garlic knots. When I got home to serve to my children I noticed the bottom of the pizza was a little burnt and the garlic knots were very hard. Called and complained, first was told they were premade, then was offered 10% off my next purchase, the employee then offered to remake for me ( would have been ok if I didn’t live 30 minutes away and a child that didn’t just have surgery), finally I sd I want a refund. Was told she didn’t know how to do it that the general manager was coming in at 5pm that I would get a call later. Still no phone call, very unhappy with the service

    Alexis Dugas
    November 17, 2022

    Pizza and garlic knots were amazing! Only problem I had was we had it delivered to the truck stop and no one called to tell me they delivered it to the front desk. I had to call and ask and then she told us it was delivered 5 minutes ago. That angered me bc our pizza was already just about cold by then. That was the whole purpose in me providing my number to call.

    Shannon Hetrick
    December 28, 2022

    This place has extremely nice and helpful employees and they have incredibly tasty pizza too. My husband was layed over, and I called Rico's because all of the reviews were excellent, and the pictures from the reviews looked great. I asked the man what was good there and he named all of the many specialty pizzas that they had, and told me what came on them. He was really nice. I picked the garden pizza and it was delicious!!! My husband brought me back two pieces and I wanted more. Lol This is a fantastic place to get an amazingly delectable pizza that will have you wanting more. Thank you, Rico's!!! We will be back. Yummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

    Alexandra Federov
    March 24, 2022

    So I'm pretty sure ketchup was used as sauce. It was very tart and vinegary in a ketchup sort of way. The little hint that was left that didn't get dried out. It was kind of hard to tell because it was so overcooked and dried out the cheese was impossible to separate. The chicken chunks were hard. From being cooked to death I would imagine. This was allegedly a buffalo pizza but I couldn't have told you that if I didn't order it. It had no flavor left except for the ketchup. They also charged extra for the blue cheese for a buffalo chicken pizza which did not have any blue cheese on it? In short, ketchup for sauce, baked to a dried crisp, inedible, disgusting. Oh and that inedible disgusting thing cost 30 bucks. And ps, I'm from NYC and this is MOST CERTAINLY NOT NYC style pizza. What it is is false advertising. I just read the reviews this place won't last long

    Casey Terese
    October 03, 2022

    I was travelling yesterday and stopped for a slice. Sounded better than Taco Bell or McDonalds. Glad I stopped! The cheese pizza was super good and I wish I would’ve bought two slices!

    Rico’s Pizza New York Style

    Our Address

    371 W Morris St, Bath, NY 14810, USA

    See Your Business Here!

    For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!