601 N Franklin St, Watkins Glen, NY 14891, USA

About Pudgies

3.9 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Jenine Kopenski
    November 13, 2022

    The Buffalo chicken pizza was hot (maybe obviously but with that flavor can be hit or miss depending on heat level lol) but great atmosphere.

    Chelsea Brown
    November 09, 2021

    I’m going to take you on my pudgie’s journey. First of all, it was the only thing open in this town past 7:30pm- we tried everywhere else and were left to patronize pudgies- the last option. We walked in and were assaulted with food pictures on the menu that should’ve clued us in to the fact that this place was NOT it... but based on the 4 star rating and steady line of customers, we pushed forth. I ordered a 1/2 order of medium wings, my boyfriend ordered a salad, we got 2 cooler sodas and an order of cannolis- the total was $32- shockingly high for what essentially boils down to one meal, but ... okay, we’ll push on. We sit down and wait for a solid 15 minutes, which is fine for wings but not a salad but also, whatever- fresh made, right? In the interim the counter girl’s boyfriend came in and demanded she come home so she can have a warm bed- she declined and he left in a huff. Food took another 7 minutes and we watched about 5 more people come in and order during our wait. When our food arrived, it was inedible. The wings were the absolute worst wings I’ve ever received or been forced to consume. The freezer burned tips, the blue cheese side that tasted like PLASTIC, the reflux inducing sauce... there was no upside. The salad was made out of a hunk of iceberg lettuce and sprinkled with subpar vegetables. A squabble amongst the staff continued to disturb our “dinner” and when we eventually left, we were met with fellow diners in the parking lot, using their cars as tables in the dark. The whole experience wasn’t just bad... it was bizarre. My concern is the 4 star review and the stream of customers - I need Lodi residents to know that it doesn’t have to be like this.... there are good, cheap, wings in the world.... please stop subjecting yourselves to this madness.

    Sydney L.
    October 02, 2022

    We got the max pack for a group of people and the pizza was HUGE! It was $83 but they must have given us 60 pieces of boneless wings and you can mix match the sauces. The worker was nice and professional. I would say the pizza is a doughy version of a Pizza Hut/ poppa johns/ dominos but it was just what we needed after a day at the wineries. I’m giving it 4 stars just because the pizza itself is more of a fast food type of pizza, not authentic. Overall it was a good experience.

    Ima Shopper
    August 21, 2022

    We got pizza and subs, both were amazing! The manager took our order because they were short staffed, but everyone was working hard and very friendly. It was more busy as it was NASCAR weekend! Store was very clean. We will definitely visit again!

    Cindy Mullaney
    October 12, 2022

    Loved their chef salad. Huge salad , all fresh to. Also ordered boneless wings they also were awesome. Clean facilities. Much better food than some of the other pudgies we have gotton food from. Will order again!!


    Our Address

    601 N Franklin St, Watkins Glen, NY 14891, USA

    See Your Business Here!

    For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!