14 E Castle St, Geneva, NY 14456, USA

About Pinky’s

3.9 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Rich Orsino
    May 17, 2022

    Hidden gem in Geneva. Owner is a great man and local legend. Friendly atmosphere and excellent food. Try going anywhere else and getting a can of Old Milwaukee beer!!

    Fae Burt
    March 26, 2022

    My brother and sister-in-law and I came down from Caledonia and Honeoye Falls respectively, to go to Pinky's with my sister, who lives in Geneva, and is a regular there, especially on Friday nights. My brother and I had the haddock park with ziti. It was absolutely DELICIOUS! We both really loved it. My sister-in-law had broiled with mac and cheese, and my sister had fish fry with a side of spaghetti. They loved theirs, too. I would definitely recommend this place. Pinky does an outstanding job, and the people at bar greeted us when we came in and when we left, as if we were all friends. Great evening.

    Robert B
    February 17, 2021

    There are not many places like Pinky's remaining in our downtowns. Wonderful homemade food (prepared by Pinky himself!) and served with good old fashion service. A true classic, sit at the bar or order out, enjoy!

    Ken Eveland
    April 05, 2019

    Pinky's is an old-time bar but NOT an "old timers bar" or "bar for the elderly" as quoted by the self described "guide" as previously reported. Yes the place is old and it could use some updating. The majority of the customers have been eating (and yes drinking) at Pinky's for many years because; #1) the Service is GREAT #2) the Owner's are Great #3) the FOOD is GREAT and the PRICES are Great. I have seen people smoking out front; but I have seen that at every establishment downtown. If more small business' could figure out how Pinky has made it for over 40 years - America would be a better place. Dinner is served Wednesday and Friday nights and lunch is served daily. Give it a try if you can find a table or seat at the bar.

    jen marrero
    November 18, 2018

    Wouldnt go in here even if you paid me. The first thing you ALWAYS see is a older drunk sitting outside smoking. No one wants to walk past a cloud of smoke to go eat. Out door decorations are out dated and dirty. One plus is ive never seen them busy so youll always get waited on quickly. This is more of a place for the elderly crowd to hang out and get drunk. Food isnt too bad. Not top on my list. It is rather clean. So thats alwats a plus. Dim lighting but i guess thats expected in a bar. Over all if your older and want a place to drink with other people of your age and dont mind clouds if cigarette smoke this is the place for you.


    Our Address

    14 E Castle St, Geneva, NY 14456, USA

    See Your Business Here!

    For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!