Mamma Maria New York Pizzeria

217 Grant Ave, Auburn, NY 13021, USA

About Mamma Maria New York Pizzeria

4.8 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Jessica Duck
    -
    April 14, 2022

    The employees were amazing, the portions tremendous, and the food delicious. I took family from overseas to eat here for lunch while shopping the plaza, and despite the chaos of a group of 6 (3 kids) in a small pizza shop, we were treated wonderfully, served quickly and kindly, and had plenty of leftovers to take home. Definitely will visit again, 5 Stars ๐Ÿ’œ

    Cait G
    -
    May 19, 2022

    It took me four times to convince my partner to stop here for a slice while we were walking around the strip mall. Seemed and smelled like legit NYC style pizza. Really wish I hadn't.. The young girl who took our order of one plain slice was nice and courteous (poor her), but the older girl at the register was absolutely MISERABLE. My partner told her to keep the change for her slice (several dollars) and was met with a grimace and "...you sure?" as she stuffed it in the tip jar. Okay, so we don't say "thank you" here.. cool. We then watched her rudely and reluctantly take an order from a father and his young son for three fresh slices of pepperoni.. they said they were fine with waiting, but she wanted to push the old, shriveled slices on them. When our slice was ready, miserable cashier shoved the slice across the counter and didn't say a word. Wow. We don't care how good the pizza is (btw, nothing to write home about).. not supporting a place with service like this.

    Lon Large
    -
    August 03, 2022

    I must admit that I love the Pizza and garlic Knotts. I would like a little more attention to the environment it really is not up to speed for cleanliness the floor is never really clean. The tables always need attention, pizza boxes and cardboard cover at least half of the indoor seating area. I know it's a successful business and it's very busy but take on one person who only does cleaning, tables, floors, walls, trash, stocking. Maybe inventory but not food service. Again I do love your product.

    Linda Vacca
    -
    August 02, 2022

    We had the spinach white lazania , delicious enough for 2 for lunch. Home made pasta? Came with 3 large bread sticks and each of us had enough for dinner also. Very reasonably priced at 8.99. 12 Oz soda was icee cold and only $1 ร—รท though Olympic enjoyed the meal. Customer service was excellent.

    R S
    -
    July 23, 2022

    Great pizza, salads, service, and prices! Everything was fresh and the food leaves you wanting to come back. Definitely recommend!

    Mamma Maria New York Pizzeria

    Our Address

    217 Grant Ave, Auburn, NY 13021, USA

    See Your Business Here!

    For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!