Keuka Restaurant

12 E Main St, Penn Yan, NY 14527, USA

About Keuka Restaurant

4.2 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Benjamin Simpson
    March 02, 2022

    I genuinely cannot remember ever having a bad experience here. I always order the same thing, and it's always fantastic! This is one of the few places I have gone that will send out a truly rare steak when ordered that way. They also have the best sauce for their clams of any local joint. Staff, service, atmosphere, food, and cleanliness are always spot on.

    Holger Lersch (fahrbier)
    August 08, 2022

    Nice location and we also had a very sweet and friendly waiter tonight, however - despite more waiters are roaming the restaurant, ours was all over the place. Due to the fact that she was very busy, we had to wait long for putting in an order, order new drinks and eventually dessert. For the long wait, the kids got a cheesecake for free. Nice! So, still I'd say service 4 stars - but in general, management should make all the waiters work. The food: Was okay, nothing special. Altogether a ok'ish experience. You can go and habe dinner at that place. Ah, and they charge you 4% for using a credit card. 🤷‍♂️

    Gene Ellis
    July 10, 2022

    After visiting the Wind Mill we stopped in Penn Yan for lunch at the Keuka Restaurant. My wife has a BBQ burger with sweet potato fries and I had a burger with bacon and Mac + cheese on the burger with onion rings. Both were cooked to our liking. Would definitely visit again when in the area.

    Vlad Loenko
    August 09, 2022

    The team at Keuka Restaurant made our special night perfect and amazing. The owner went out of his way to work with us and make a smaller menu and even made sure to throw in the apps ahead of time while we drove to the packed restaurant on Friday evening! We are so grateful for such amazing service staff who took care of us and the stellar kitchen staff who put love into their delicacies! Would recommend, without hesitation, to anyone who is getting married or having a wedding rehearsal dinner. It was flawless and went off without a hitch!

    Kenneth Pace
    September 30, 2022

    We had modest expectations going in as we were traveling and had to grab a bite to eat on the road. The atmosphere was like a good hometown place. The servers were attentive and very pleasant. We were delightfully rewarded with some very very good food. I started off with an Irish coffee that had a little kick to it. My entree was the Fish Fry. Tasty and a great portion. The cole slaw was good as well. My wife had the shrimp scampi. We have had many shrimp scampi on the road and have been disappointed over and over again. Not here.. Not this time. The shrimp were freshly prepared and tender. The pasta cooked to near perfection. And the sauce had just enough balance of garlic, butter, wine, and with a hint of lemon to delight these diners. Also the sauce adhered to the pasta with just the right consistency. It wasn't too sticky nor too thin. Highly recommended Thanks for a wonderful meal that capped a good day of exploring the area around Penn Yan.

    Keuka Restaurant

    Our Address

    12 E Main St, Penn Yan, NY 14527, USA

    See Your Business Here!

    For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!