The Crystal Lake Cafe

4367 E Covert Rd, Interlaken, NY 14847, USA

About The Crystal Lake Cafe

4.2 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Ed Fischer
    November 28, 2017

    Excellent food and wine in a charming atmosphere. Had an excellent meat and cheese plate with a glass of Americana Red, and Chicken Riggie pasta. I had a visit from a friendly dinner guest!

    Teresa Miner
    September 02, 2019

    We were not offered any drinks, just given water. Waitress was rude. When I thanked her for taking our order, her response was "Yup". Dogs being allowed in the dining area. Do not see how this isn't a health violation. My food was gross. Ordered the fish fry. Came out overcooked and greasy. The fries tasted like the fish. Will never go there again

    Da Dee
    August 23, 2019

    We ate lunch at the Crystal Lake Cafe today because our choices were sparse. We had just been to the Taughannock Falls State Park and were very hot from the hiking trails. It was hot and humid (August 21, 2019). When asked if we wanted to eat outdoors or indoors, we asked if the indoor section was air conditioned. We were told flat out that it was. Well, it wasn't. But being so tired, we stayed in the non-air conditioning. That set the tone of how our service was going to go. To cut to the chase, the Grilled Cheese, the Cuban sandwiches, and the wings were fine however, the potato fries were in the oil a little too long. Our waitress never checked to see if everything was alright with our meals nor refilled our water, basically forgot that we existed totally. You say, "Well maybe it was busy or maybe we were in an out of the way table?" No to both. We were one of only two tables there and were right in the middle of the dining area. And, our waitress was friendly and outgoing to the only other table there - a Caucasian couple - as a matter of fact, she asked THEM how their meal was and was very nice to them. Yes, we are not Caucasian. We left a 15% tip (I know, we shouldn't have even left that) and wrote on the receipt what we experienced. Our advice, skip this place. No food is good enough to tolerate this kind of treatment.

    Abigail Hodde
    May 01, 2016

    We visited during the Wine & Herb Festival and though the wait was a little long (but not surprising with how busy the place was!) the food was absolutely delicious. The recipes are unique, the quality of the ingredients astounding. I was thoroughly impressed and can't wait to eat here again.

    Karen Valenta
    November 25, 2017

    Prompt service. Food was very good with an interesting, varied menu for such a small place. I had NE clam chowder and corn fritters with chipotle honey butter. My husband had the same soup with a tasty, ample sized smoked salmon salad. After a tasty meal on to a wine tasting @ Americana Winery.

    The Crystal Lake Cafe

    Our Address

    4367 E Covert Rd, Interlaken, NY 14847, USA

    See Your Business Here!

    For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!