The BBQ Shack/Donuts Done Right

2447 NY-54A, Penn Yan, NY 14527, USA

About The BBQ Shack/Donuts Done Right

4.7 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    May 26, 2022

    Food was great. I had ribs and the wife had the brisket. Coleslaw and Mac salad were as expected. In time I hope they can dress the place up a bit. But don't judge this book by its cover, it's definitely worth the stop.

    Sean ODell
    May 14, 2022

    We saw the good reviews online and thought we had to stop in. Their food is absolutely incredible, very affordable for the portion size. You have to stop here if you're within any range of it or passing through. The owners are super nice and extremely generous human beings. The donuts are absolutely incredible as well. They're all made with fresh ingredients and you have to try them!! Such an amazing family run operation!!! We look forward to our next visit.

    Nora Buchman (Nora)
    June 08, 2022

    BBQ was decent - ribs were the highlight, super tender and melt in your mouth with a beautiful smokey flavor. Pulled pork wasn't anything to write home about, beans came out of a can, fries & home fries are super crispy and tasty. Was disappointed that donuts were down but we were there an hour or so before closing. Lady behind the counter was ultra sweet and prices are fairly low for the amount of food you get. Worth a stop.

    October 21, 2022

    Let's get straight to the point, I was in town for business and the local boys asked me to get some BBQ with them. We walked in, I wasn't sure due to a very home style environment (relaxing chairs, house furniture, etc.). I ordered "the puckered pig" & Mac & cheese....GOD DAMN that was good!!!! I ate the whole thing and was pleasantly full. If you really want to order a great looking large plate, get a garbage plate (say what?), yes a garbage plate. ENJOY

    R J
    June 13, 2022

    We decided to stop here for dinner on a Saturday afternoon in early June while in the Geneva area and after reading the good reviews. Seating inside is a bit limited to just five or six tables, but most of their business is take-out any way, so we were able to find an empty table easily. We ordered a pulled pork sandwich with cole slaw and salt potatoes, and a half-rack of BBQ ribs dinner with salt potatoes. Very friendly service and our meals were served up in just a few minutes. The pulled pork sandwich was good; tasty and a generous portion. The half-rack of BBQ ribs consisted of five ribs with meat on them that were overcooked, dry, a bit chewy, and not much flavor. Definitely not the best ribs I've ever had. Very disappointing after reading the good reviews and expecting something much better. The cole slaw was good and the salt potatoes were OK. Our total bill with beverages was a bit over $41 plus tax, with the ribs and salt potatoes dinner making up $25 of that total. Definitely overpriced for the quality and quantity of ribs that I was served. Maybe the ribs that I received weren't the norm for here, but we don't plan on visiting again.

    The BBQ Shack/Donuts Done Right

    Our Address

    2447 NY-54A, Penn Yan, NY 14527, USA

    See Your Business Here!

    For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!